Do Our Universities Need “Thought Leaders” at the Helm?

Education |
By Michael Q. McShane | Read Time 2 minutes minutes

File this under the grass isn’t always greener.

The San Francisco Chronicle revealed last week that the University of California–Berkeley paid consultants $200,000 to shape public opinion of Chancellor Nicolas Dirks as a “key thought leader” in order to “increase exposure and awareness” of his “vision for higher education.” This appeared to be done as a sop to potential donors, who might be more likely to give to a university with a visionary at the helm. But given the fact that Dirks decided to step down this week, it’s left the university with egg on its face.

All schadenfreude aside, this incident does raise a bigger question: Who do we want at the helm of our flagship public universities?  Do we want noted academics who might have particular insight on how to best educate students or conduct research? Do we want politicians who can navigate the complex web of state and federal government and their often-conflicting mandates for the university? Do we want businesspeople who have experience running the multi-billion-dollar organizations that these institutions have become? Do we want visionary thought leaders (whatever that is) who can chart a new course for higher education in the state?

To be totally honest, I don’t have a good answer to these questions. However, as the state takes the next several months to review how the University of Missouri system is functioning and the essential role that leadership plays in the four campuses that comprise it, deciding who we want at the helm will be important and necessary step.

About the Author

Michael Q. McShane is Senior Fellow of Education Policy at the Show-Me Institute.  A former high school teacher, he earned a Ph.D. in education policy from the University of Arkansas, an M.Ed. from the University of Notre Dame, and a B.A. in English from St. Louis University. McShanes analyses and commentary have been published widely in the media, including in the Huffington Post, National Affairs, USA Today, and The Washington Post. He has also been featured in education-specific outlets such as Teachers College Commentary, Education Week, Phi Delta Kappan, and Education Next. In addition to authoring numerous white papers, McShane has had academic work published in Education Finance and Policy and the Journal of School Choice. He is the editor of New and Better Schools (Rowman and Littlefield, 2015), the author of Education and Opportunity (AEI Press, 2014), and coeditor of Teacher Quality 2.0 (Harvard Education Press, 2014) and Common Core Meets Education Reform (Teachers College Press, 2013).

Similar Stories

Support Us

Headline to go here about the good with supporting us.

Donate
Man on Horse Charging